BBC Horizon’s “E-Cigarettes: Miracle or Menace?” – Truth or Treachery?

Last Sunday’s Horizon on BBC Two focused on e-cigarettes, so it's time to check out if this episode got its facts right amid the lies and stigma surrounding vaping. 

During the programme, presenter Michael Mosley took up vaping for a month having never smoked a day in his life. This isn’t advisable, but then again the man has already swallowed a tapeworm and done the 5:2 diet, so we’re not going to judge him.

Mosley talked to the experts about vaping and the results were surprising. Most experts he spoke to agreed that e-cigarettes were much less harmful than conventional cigarettes, and even he wasn’t concerned by the short term effects of vaping. 

Nicotine Addiction?

His biggest concern was becoming addicted to nicotine, however this turned out to not happen. He instead found that having to puff on the e-cigarette so regularly soon became a chore to him. What’s more, his children were unimpressed and had no intention of copying him, thinking that it wasn’t cool.

In fact, new research seemed to indicate that nicotine alone is not as addictive as we once thought, and it is potentially the combination of nicotine and other chemicals present in cigarettes that causes the addiction.

Nicotine can even have its benefits in some cases – a study in the US has recently been funded to explore the potential benefits of nicotine on patients with mild cognitive impairment (an Alzheimer’s precursor). They’ll be given regular nicotine patches or a placebo patch and will receive health checks and cognition tests to see if nicotine can help their memory.

What About Smokers?

The programme also followed regular smokers as they tried to kick the habit. The smokers tried a range of techniques designed to help quit smoking – chewing nicotine gum, wearing nicotine patches – as well as e-cigarettes and even trying to go cold turkey.

The results clearly showed that e-cigarettes do have a part to play in helping people quit smoking, even if manufacturers and retailers can’t fully say it yet due to the obvious regulation around smoking cessation equipment. During the study, e-cigarettes were much more effective in helping people to quit smoking than going cold turkey.

So It’s Totally Safe?

Well, not entirely. The show also covered the other side of the equation. At the end of his month of heavy vaping, Mosley showed signs of increased inflammation in his lungs. While this rapidly reversed when he stopped vaping, it does show that vaping isn’t without its risks.

Even with the potential risks, Mosley came out fully in support of vaping as a smoking alternative, both for the health benefits and its potential use as a smoking cessation tool.

Blu 2.0 Golden Tobacco Liquidpods (18mg) £6.99    In stock now View Info Provides a consistent vapour in a rich golden tobacco flavour Ceramic pod technology for a smooth vaping experience Now provides roughly 25% more puffs per pod Magnetic lock for fast and secure refills			EDGE GO E-Cigarette Device £10.99    In stock now View Info E-cigarette device for use with EDGE GO pods Sleek and slender device is discreet to use Buttonless design for easy activation Petite 10.5cm length perfect for on-the-go use			OK Vape Tobacco Extra-High Nicotine E-Cigarette Refills (20mg) £6.99    In stock now View Info Tobacco-flavoured electronic cigarette refill Suitable for the OK Vape Rechargeable E-Cigarette Extra-high nicotine strength of 20mg Each pack contains 5 refills, with bulk offers available Available from £5.20 per pack! FREE OK Vape Starter Kit Offer: Enter switch2ok at checkout			Lost Mary BM600 Pineapple Ice Disposable Vape (20mg) £4.95    In stock now View Info Disposable vape device in a tasty pineapple flavour Provides 600 puffs per vape, roughly the same as 20 cigarettes Bright and colourful design in a conveniently compact case Mix and match 10 of any flavour to reduce price to £3.80 per device
Elf Bar 600 Strawberry Raspberry Cherry Ice Disposable Vape Pen (20mg) £4.99    In stock now View Info Disposable vape pen supplied in a delicious mixed berry flavour Provides 600 puffs per bar, roughly the same as 20 cigarettes Compact, portable and drag-activated for a great vape experience  Mix and match 10 of any flavour to reduce price to £3.80 per device			OK Vape Tobacco High Nicotine E-Cigarette Refills (18mg) £6.99    In stock now View Info Tobacco-flavoured electronic cigarette refill Suitable for the OK Vape Rechargeable E-Cigarette High nicotine strength of 18mg Each pack contains 5 refills, with bulk offers available Available from £5.20 per pack! FREE OK Vape Starter Kit Offer: Enter switch2ok at checkout			OK Vape Menthol High Nicotine E-Cigarette Refills (18mg) £6.99    In stock now View Info Menthol-flavoured electronic cigarette refill Suitable for the OK Vape Rechargeable E-Cigarette High nicotine strength of 18mg Each pack contains 5 refills, with bulk offers available Available from £5.20 per pack! FREE OK Vape Starter Kit Offer: Enter switch2ok at checkout			Vuse Pro ePod Golden Tobacco Refill Pods (12mg) £6.49    In stock now View Info Refill pods for use with Vuse Pro and Vuse ePod devices Classic tobacco flavour with toasty caramel notes Features nicotine salts and a strength of 12mg This double pack lasts up to a massive 1900 puffs
OK Vape E-Cigarette Nicotine-Free Menthol Refill Cartridges (0mg) £6.99    In stock now View Info Menthol flavour refill cartridges for the OK Rechargeable E-Cigarette Each pack contains five cartridges and lasts for the equivalent of 125 traditional cigarettes Nicotine-free with 0mg of nicotine in each cartridge Bulk offers available starting at £5.20 per pack FREE OK Vape Starter Kit Offer: Enter switch2ok at checkout			EDGE Strawberry and Lime E-Liquid (Pack of 5) £11.99    In stock now View Info Strawberry and lime flavoured e-liquid Nicotine strengths: 6mg, 12mg and 18mg VG: 50%, PG: 50% Made in the UK			10 Motives E-Cigarette Tobacco Refill Cartridges Saver Pack (20 Packs) £119.99    In stock now View Info Tobacco refill cartridges for the 10 Motives Rechargeable E-Cigarette Each refill is a nicotine equivalent of up to 25 cigarettes Available in 11mg, 16mg, and 20mg nicotine strengths Saver pack containing 20 packs (80 refills in total)			EDGE Very Menthol E-Liquid (Pack of 5) £11.99    In stock now View Info Menthol flavoured e-liquid Nicotine strengths: 6mg, 12mg and 18mg VG: 50%, PG: 50% Made in the UK